It’s unclear where the 90 percent success rate statistic comes from at
all
A number
of media outlets have reported in recent days that China has deployed a new
missile defense system on many of its ships that has a 90 percent success rate
against hypersonic missiles. The same reports also unwittingly highlight that
this assertion is false.
…Type 1130 CIWS can’t
shoot down hypersonic missiles. As noted above, these reports claim that the
Type 1130 CIWS can target missiles traveling at up to four times the speed of
sound, or Mach 4. As impressive as these reports make Mach 4 out to be, it
doesn’t reach hypersonic levels. To constitute hypersonic, the missile must
travel at five times the speed of sound (Mach 5) or greater. NASA further categorizes speeds
as hypersonic (between Mach 5 and Mach 10) and high hypersonic (between Mach 10
and Mach 25). This oversight— calling Mach 4 hypersonic— is particularly
surprising given that it was featured on science and technology websites
Gizmodo and Engineering.com.
There are other smaller issues with the claims as well. For example, no country currently deploys hypersonic
missiles, raising the question of how the Type 1130 achieved its 90
percent success rate in shooting them down.
No comments:
Post a Comment